Buying guide · Compare

Apple refurbished vs. us
vs. brand new.

A side-by-side, honest table — built so you can decide in five minutes whether to buy from Apple, from us, or pay full price for a sealed box.

By Rick · Updated April 24, 2026 · 5-minute read

There are three real options for buying a Mac in 2026. Apple's Certified Refurbished store, an independent reseller like us, or paying full price for a brand new sealed box. Most buyers don't know how the three actually compare on price, warranty, and what happens if the machine breaks. So here is the table we use when customers ask.

The comparison table

Apple Refurbished LuxuriousComputers Brand New (Apple)
Typical price 15% off new 25–40% off new Full retail
Warranty length 1 year 1 year (extendable to 2) 1 year (extendable via AppleCare+)
What the warranty does Repair the failed part Ship a replacement Mac in 48 hours, you ship the broken one back on our label Repair at Apple service center
Accident protection Not included (AppleCare+ extra) Not included (AppleCare+ extra) Not included (AppleCare+ extra)
Inventory size Limited — only what Apple itself returned Large — auctions, fleet refreshes, estate sales, trade-ins Made-to-order from factory
Configuration choices Whatever they happen to have Whatever we happen to have — but we can hunt your config Build to spec
Shipping speed 3–5 business days Same-day before 2pm ET, 2–4 day delivery 5–10 business days for custom builds
Free shipping Yes Yes, on orders over $500 Yes
Cosmetic condition Like new — Apple grades strictly Like new — we grade and disclose any wear in the listing New — sealed factory box
Trade-in Apple Trade In credit Trade-in credit on your purchase, including broken machines and non-Apple laptops Apple Trade In credit
Returns 14 days, free return shipping 30 days, free return shipping, no restocking fee 14 days, free return shipping
In-person support Apple Store (where available) Marion, Ohio storefront — Tue-Sat 10am-7pm Apple Store (where available)
Who answers the phone Tier-1 support center Rick Tier-1 support center
Financing Apple Card monthly payments Klarna and Affirm at checkout Apple Card monthly payments

What actually changes between the three

Price

Apple's refurbished store gives you about 15% off their full retail price. We give you 25 to 40% off Apple's full retail price. The reason isn't a quality difference — it's a supply difference. Apple only refurbishes their own returns, which is a small, expensive pool. We source from auction houses, corporate fleet refreshes, estate sales, and customer trade-ins, which is a much bigger and cheaper pool.

What "warranty" means

Both Apple and we offer a one-year warranty on a refurbished Mac. The difference is what the word means in practice. Apple repairs the failed part, which means you ship the laptop back, wait 3-7 days, and get your machine back with a replacement component. We replace the entire machine. You email us, we approve the claim, you get a different refurbished Mac of the same model in 48 hours, and you ship the broken one back on our prepaid label. You're back to working in two business days. Same one-year coverage on paper, very different lived experience.

Where you can walk in

Apple has stores in major cities. Marion, Ohio is not a major city. If you're in north-central Ohio, your nearest Apple Store is two hours away in Columbus or Cleveland. Our flagship is on Center Street in Marion, Tuesday through Saturday, 10am-7pm. You can walk in, talk to Rick, look at demo units, drop off a trade-in, or pick up an order in person.

Inventory and configuration

Brand new from Apple, you build the machine to spec — pick storage, memory, screen size. From any refurbisher, including Apple's own, you take what's on the shelf. The shelves change daily. If you need a specific configuration and don't see it on our site, message Rick — he can usually find it within a week through our procurement network.

When to buy from Apple's refurb store

When to buy from us

When to buy brand new

Honestly, almost never — for most people. Brand new from Apple makes sense if:

Honest disclosure: We're not the cheapest listing on the entire internet. There are random sellers and marketplace flippers who beat our price by another $50 or so. What you give up to save it there is the bench testing, the fresh macOS install, the verified battery health, and a real one-year warranty backed by a real store. We've seen those purchases come into our shop for repair more times than we can count.

The bottom line

For 80% of buyers, our refurbished Macs are the right call. You save more, the warranty does more, the return window is longer, and you can drive to the store. For another 15%, Apple's refurb store is fine. For the remaining 5% — people who specifically need a brand-new configuration that doesn't exist refurbished yet — paying full price makes sense.

If you're not sure which group you're in, hit the chat button and tell Rick what you're trying to do. He'll point you to whichever option actually saves you the most.

Ready to compare specific models?

Tell Rick the model you're considering at Apple and he'll match it from our shelf with the price difference and warranty difference clearly laid out.

Talk to Rick →